Good morning! Should be a little more active today! So based on my skimming over the past couple of pages, it seems that we have 2 role claims. I think it’d be important for others to counter claim those roles if they are in fact those roles. There are a lot of arguments I need to re-read, but if n...

I didn't say it outs the doctor, I said it narrows the number of people that it could be. Fake claiming Shallan would be smart BECAUSE it's a less important role, that someone might be less bothered about counterclaiming. The mafia then have one role confirmed that they don't care about, so any oth...

So, for some reason, I'm being suspected, but that's fine. Lotha asked me for a role claim, so I'm giving one. I'm Shallan. As far as my suspicions of Ubik, there's nothign concrete, as you all have said. I'm actually complimenting Ubik. Every game he phrases his posts in a way that make me go &quo...

Wait did I miss a post? @Inky, what would you like to talk out? That I’m Dalinar or that I don’t have any strong mafia leads so I’m purely guessing Timo? (Then I brought up quiet Cameron, because usually quiet Cameron is a Cameron trying to hide something for better or for worse) All good! It was T...

If nobody counter claims, I'm not sure I'm willing to vote for Summer. I think she's suspicious, and I know it could be a mafia trap to find our leader, but it's our most important role. We can't just casually vote her out, if nobody else speaks up? The Dissident - I think I believe him. The only w...

He's in the middle for me as I do see his logic in his posts and I think he's been making good points as a logical player. My main discomfort with his position in my list (which I was referring to) is that I don't have much evidence that he is town or mafia- just that he's good at logical arguments...

Ok Dissident Due Diligence time. I’m going to link his posts since there aren’t that many, and I’ll separate them between days one and two. This should make it easy to quickly jump into them and determine how everybody reads them. DAY ONE #1 #2 #3 (Drunkgate?) #4 #5 DAY TWO #6 #7 There is some fluff...

Just popping in, haven't read too much of the last page. But realized I didn't mention and should mention the following: I recieved an offer and declined it during the night phase to join the mafia. [Ubik] get in here, we've got a live one!! I was going to go confirm my town reads, going to check i...

Fair enough, I’ve been a stinky leader this go around, but if my fellow knights really want to kill off a mafia member today, overthrowing your “leader” is not the way to go. Where’s my niece at? She should be able to vouch for me. But also, I haven’t given you a good reason to vote for anyone else...

Thanks, Lotha! Appreciate the response. I'm bad at multiquoting so I'm just numbering the points I'm responding to here, added them to yours as well for ease. 1. Just to answer the last part first, the order was concrete in that the higher ones I had as likelier town, but obviously the gaps between ...

Good god the coding, I don't know what happened. I'll try to fix it.

Ok I'm back. Going to go through some posts one by one and pick out a few things I want to clarify. I’m going to cut a few things out to keep this as short as possible but… no promises. 2. Ubik So far have agreed with most of his points and he seems to be taking a very rational approach, also has no...

Ok so I posted reads halfway through the first day phase and not a lot has changed, but here’s where I am right now. TOWN Ubik: Admittedly, I’m having some doubts here. I do still see like… classic town Ubik things in his posts from day one, I do like that he was asking about the offer in night one,...

Fair question, but there's quite a big difference to my eyes - I'm not asking whether someone would hypothetically accept (and I agree, there's no good answer you can give to that), I'm asking if they got an offer, as one was almost certainly made last night. I want to see what people say first but...

My list Green Zone. Nobody. Yellow Zone. 1. Lotha . She seemed genuinely upset with Incon’s opening on day one. She could have acted that of course, but it seemed real to me. Most of her day one posts are on that subject. Aside from that, she disagreed with me, but everybody who touched that subjec...

Nice, well done the doc. One question to start the day - did anyone receive an offer from the mafia? The doc like The Rock? =D So I'm going to ask you the same question I asked Lotha about this yesterday, will you believe people if they say no? And conversely, where would you go with it if they sai...

Well frig nice job, Kaladin! On one hand I hope you didn't protect me in the night, on the other if you did and I was the target, I thank you for the assist. I really... don't know how to approach today now that we're basically repeating day one all over again since we don't have a kill to analyze. ...

2. Lotha spoke on the whole claiming early and the above statement is sort of an echo of what she has said. But her post encourages more claims. I for one hate role claiming and think it usually shoots town in the foot. Could you please do me a favour and point out where Lotha's encouraging more cl...

Aww, no PM'ing. Well, okay. Nothing's gonna happen anyway. Incon, I'm prepared to work with you, consider you've taken a central position and seem to be working in favor of the townies. But I'm not fully convinced. I totally understand your reservations, I would be cautious about somebody pulling s...

I'd probably put you in the middle of my rankings. I think there's a good chance you are one of the vigilantes, but there's also a chance you're mafia trying to make a play to get a real vigilante to claim their role against you. Being day 1, there's nobody in my rankings I'd say is for sure a town...