"WHAT'S YOUR FAVORITE SCARY MOVIE?"-MAFIA GAME!- TOWNIES WIN

[zazthespaz]

I'm voting for the first person to call my mom. Your role will not be considered.

[zazisaspaz]

WAIT! I had an epiphany while cleaning my garage! The mafia would only know that Gale investigated someone and then find out that someone’s role. Therefore, mafia would not have known Ubik was Gale (unless he investigates himself). So it must have been a random guess, unless Ubik saying he had To tell the police was enough for them to guess he might be Gale. This doesn’t help us figure out who did it, but... well there is no “but,” so just accept my additional non-helpful info.

[The Dissident]

I believe it would be beneficial to think about who Ubik would have looked into based on their past playing experience. I don't know how they operate so I can't really say anything in regards to their playstyle or not.

[AB4Lyfe]

Feel kinda bad for Shea that your definition of “experience mafia” = not Shea.

Hard to disagree with the logic though. Sorry Shea.

Oh my god, Shea I'm sorry I really didn't mean it that way!! Please don't be offended, I just meant based on how I've seen you play as mafia, what I'm thinking went down in night one isn't your typical style of play.

This is pretty funny Poor Canadian Baken.

I agree with the thought Shea isn’t Mafia, and Summer’s point that the Mafia took a shot in the dark because there’s no way they would have known Ubik was Mafia. So, now what?

[SHEAKENBAKEN]

Feel kinda bad for Shea that your definition of “experience mafia” = not Shea.

Hard to disagree with the logic though. Sorry Shea.

Its okay, Andy.

Oh my god, Shea I'm sorry I really didn't mean it that way!! Please don't be offended, I just meant based on how I've seen you play as mafia, what I'm thinking went down in night one isn't your typical style of play.

*takes it that way*....is offended

[Inconquerable]

WAIT! I had an epiphany while cleaning my garage! The mafia would only know that Gale investigated someone and then find out that someone’s role. Therefore, mafia would not have known Ubik was Gale (unless he investigates himself). So it must have been a random guess, unless Ubik saying he had To tell the police was enough for them to guess he might be Gale. This doesn’t help us figure out who did it, but... well there is no “but,” so just accept my additional non-helpful info.

I think, and Micky can correct me if I'm wrong, but the role was that mafia could look in on Gale's investigation and if Gale found a mafia, they could then kill Gale no matter who the player was. That's the way I read it anyway.

[Micky]

WAIT! I had an epiphany while cleaning my garage! The mafia would only know that Gale investigated someone and then find out that someone’s role. Therefore, mafia would not have known Ubik was Gale (unless he investigates himself). So it must have been a random guess, unless Ubik saying he had To tell the police was enough for them to guess he might be Gale. This doesn’t help us figure out who did it, but... well there is no “but,” so just accept my additional non-helpful info.

I think, and Micky can correct me if I'm wrong, but the role was that mafia could look in on Gale's investigation and if Gale found a mafia, they could then kill Gale no matter who the player was. That's the way I read it anyway.

Wrong! Gale investigated the killer without knowing their identity. Mafia got lucky.

Also, if you read Gale's death post, there is a bolded sentence, it is a wink at Ubik because he posted that earlier on in the thread on Day 1 and mafia decided to use that one line as their guess that he was Gale.

[Micky]

Also if you guys don’t start voting, starting with day 3, I wi automatically send the game into night Mode

[Andy92]

So is it gonna come to this now.

[Inconquerable]

Ok well I read the role very incorrectly, and now I'm doubly not sure what to think. We can't just throw out votes for anybody at random because we have to be careful of Sidney dying, but we've got to get something going. The only thing I'm confident in (but not 100% sure of), is Summer's innocence because she didn't post on the first day so I don't know if she would have even been on to do anything in night one. I'll do some reading and see if I come up with anything else.

[Micky]

So is it gonna come to this now.

Pretty much

[SHEAKENBAKEN]

VOTE: The Dissident

dont take this personally, Dissident. Micky made me do it.

[Inconquerable]

Just curious, Shea, how did you decide on voting for Dissident? Give me a reason to jump on board with you.

[SHEAKENBAKEN]

Just curious, Shea, how did you decide on voting for Dissident? Give me a reason to jump on board with you.

See the subject line and the fine print

[Micky]

Just curious, Shea, how did you decide on voting for Dissident? Give me a reason to jump on board with you.

See the subject line and the fine print

I never threatened you, jerk.

[Inconquerable]

Just curious, Shea, how did you decide on voting for Dissident? Give me a reason to jump on board with you.

See the subject line and the fine print

Yeah I saw that, but he didn't tell you who to vote for I would imagine. So why Dissident?

[Micky]

Just curious, Shea, how did you decide on voting for Dissident? Give me a reason to jump on board with you.

See the subject line and the fine print

Yeah I saw that, but he didn't tell you who to vote for I would imagine. So why Dissident?

I didn’t tell him who to vote for

[SHEAKENBAKEN]

Just curious, Shea, how did you decide on voting for Dissident? Give me a reason to jump on board with you.

See the subject line and the fine print

I never threatened you, jerk.

Wow Micky first threats now name calling?!

[SHEAKENBAKEN]

Just curious, Shea, how did you decide on voting for Dissident? Give me a reason to jump on board with you.

See the subject line and the fine print

Yeah I saw that, but he didn't tell you who to vote for I would imagine. So why Dissident?

Just cause

[zazthespaz]

Have we reached the point in the game where we can "vote: shea" without consequence?