Ties That Bind
I am sorry, but I can not see any melody in the chorus, and no atmosphere during the song. It is really just all too flat for me. But I fully comprehend how taste and perception are different, and how "someone trash it is gold to the other one" (something like that).
One by one - I can see the reasons.
Break Me Down - Not their best, I agree. Although, it has a few good moments.
Make It Right - Don't you think a little bit before the bridge and on, it is just awesome?
Watch Your Words - for me, the perfect combination between heavy and melody.
Home - I know, sounds a bit generic, but I kinda like it. Catchy.
Breathe Again - very, very Creedish.
Peace is Broken - really? I like very much xD (I love the part when Myles and Mark sing along).